Does the New Urbanism movement successfully translate its theoretical ideals into the creation of functional, high-quality communities? Jill Grant, a scholar in planning and design, evaluates the gap between the movement's stated goals—such as walkability, social cohesion, and environmental sustainability—and the actual outcomes observed in modern developments. By analyzing the evolution of planning paradigms, she provides a framework for understanding how design philosophies influence social interaction and urban form.

Experts recognize this work as a critical, balanced assessment of New Urbanism that avoids the typical promotional tone found in design literature. Readers frequently note the academic rigor of the prose, making it a valuable resource for students and practitioners of urban planning.